Jacob Geller Can Go Fuck Himself Forever

I am not “moving forward," and neither should you.

A screenshot of Jacob Geller from his YouTube video, "A Joint Statement on Moving Forward." Geller, shoulders up, addresses the camera. A dark background is behind him.
A screenshot of Jacob Geller from his YouTube video, "A Joint Statement on Moving Forward."

The only ethical thing to do is to deplatform Jacob Geller.

In case you’re unaware, Geller is a self-confessed rapist, who was best known for his leftist video essays about video games – that is, until a month ago, when a document surfaced from a Title IX investigation indicating he’d been penalized for sexual misconduct, which he later corroborated in a statement on Bluesky.

In the ensuing month, Geller kept quiet on his biggest platforms, YouTube and Patreon, continuing to collect revenue from his subscribers and fans. 

Today, he resurfaced on YouTube with a solemn eight-minute video about the future of his channel. In it, he shared a statement he claimed was from the person he sexually assaulted and indicated he intends to continue making content.

That statement discussed, briefly, the personal impact of what Geller did, the reopening of the wound when the information was shared without the survivor’s consent online, and indicated her desire to move on.

Geller, too, would like to move on. He said he would not be listing the things he did to atone for the sexual assault because he owes his apology only to her. In the video, he speaks as if the tweet that brought attention to the Title IX document, which became a part of the public record years ago, was the impetus for all of this. As if that is what harmed the victim most, and all the public fallout, the discourse and the statements, were solely that user’s fault, but that is a lie.

Everything that is happening right now, everything that harmed this victim, is the direct consequence of Geller choosing to rape her all of those years ago, then pursue a media career.

When Geller raped this person, he loaded a gun. He then pulled the trigger by constructing a career in the public eye, willfully and inevitably inviting the public to scrutinize his personal life.

He worked closely with other survivors and built the trust of his audience, deceiving them with a distinct lie of omission as he espoused progressive values. He asked for and took their money, knowing some of them must be survivors, and used it to better his own lifestyle.

He took advantage of his audience and his coworkers. He made them unknowingly complicit in his harm. He harmed them.

This issue is not simply a question of retrospective justice, though, but a question of prospective safety. 

Geller spent the last decade building power, power he still has and has made no efforts to forfeit or distance himself from. Rape and sexual violence are crimes of power. The more you have, the easier they are to get away with.

For a supposedly repentant man, Geller sure did eagerly place himself in a position of power where he could easily groom or sexually harass people. We’ve seen so many internet celebrities abuse their power in this exact way, and that is exactly why we can not let him keep it.

He has shown that he does not have the character to be trusted with this platform. By allowing him to keep it, we’d become knowingly complicit in whatever future harms he causes.

This bullet has been traveling, in slow motion, for over ten years now. 

Except the bullet is not a bullet. It will not kill him. In fact, he said as much himself: “I am going to keep working. Keep striving to be the person I want to be, and I’m going to keep putting out essays here.”

He went on to say that it is our responsibility to decide how to feel about it, an abdicating his own responsibility – but he knows, as a savvy internet creator, what happens when survivors speak online. He believes he will, at least from some contingent of his audience (seriously, check his current Patreon numbers), continue receiving many, if not all, of the benefits of the life he’s built.

We live in a rape culture, where rapists like Geller do not have to carry the weight of what they’ve done. If we let him, he will continue on, business as usual, because he can.

He’s already attempting to integrate this assault into his internet persona, the reformed rapist, saying his writing “has never been about the flawlessness of his character,” and in fact, the rape is why he cares so much.

“I know how deeply I regret it, and how determined I am to never do that kind of harm again,” Geller said, “but I think the work I’ve done here, with my essays, is meaningful.” [Emphasis my own.]

In this, Geller demonstrates his commitment to what has become one of our ultimate Post-#MeToo rape myths: that men with sufficient talent, be they swimmers or video essayists, should be valued above the survivors they hurt.

Geller claimed the survivor, who he calls Jane, told him his channel “has had no negative effect on her life,” but this is, again, another obfuscation of his responsibility. We know that to be untrue because the statement itself notes the harm of this information being public, and without the channel, that harm never could have happened.

I do mean survivors, plural, though.

Because Geller’s harm has not been limited to the person he calls Jane. By choosing this career, he has multiplied that harm over his millions of followers, his thousands of Patreon subscribers, his colleagues, and even people like me, who were only tangentially aware of him before all of this. Survivors online had to relive their own trauma as users across the internet made excuses for Geller.

That’s a legitimate harm, and those survivors deserve to have their voices heard, their justice pursued.

What does it mean when a man rapes someone, says sorry, makes a sub-ten-minute video about it, and we let him continue to occupy the halls of power? What message does that send to survivors everywhere?

It is a message of rape culture. It says, “It happened, that sucks, but there’s nothing to be done. We’re powerless!”

We are not powerless. Jacob Geller must experience a consequence that is, on some level, proportionate to the harm he has done. A semester of missed school doesn’t cut it. Losing some business does not cut it.

Ultimately, the only people who can take away Geller’s power are the people who gave it to him in the first place.

So what should we, the public, do with Jacob Geller?

De-platform the fuck out of him, that’s what. Make it so he can’t profit more off of the false good-guy persona he spent years building. Make it so it is harder for him to engage in this behavior again.

Make it so survivors know they will be believed, and not just believed, but dignified with the barest grain of sand resembling justice. Make it so they know just because a man has made some cool art, that’s not more important than their pain.

Make it so survivors never have to see his face again. Make it so we can forget about him. Make it so he has to get a real job. Make it so maybe, one day, there are no more men like Jacob Geller. Make it stick, because it didn’t for Kevin Spacey or Brock Turner, and it hasn’t yet for the Cornell Seven.

Make it so for once, just this once, that bullet he chose to fire all those years ago kills his career.


Want more of The Backbone News?

The Backbone News is a feminist, antifascist news outlet that's committed to radically honest commentary and investigations that hold power to account.

If you believe these stories matter, you can subscribe for free to get my journalism in your inbox.

If you want to support me and the work I do, you can join the paid tier to unlock access to all of my future commentary pieces, the ability to comment on the site, and other perks, all for only $5/month. It helps me keep doing this.


Subscribe to The Backbone News

Don’t miss out on the latest issues. Sign up now to get access to the library of members-only issues.
jamie@example.com
Subscribe